Why Good Governance Isn't Enough
| By Michelle Wright
Much of the conversation around charitable governance still assumes that the sector’s primary challenge is compliance. It is not. The real challenge emerging across charities – and particularly across arts, culture and heritage organisations – is whether existing governance systems can operate under conditions of permanent instability.
Over the past decade, charities have experienced declining public funding, increased operational costs, greater safeguarding responsibilities and increasing pressure to evidence impact, inclusion and accountability simultaneously. Yet governance structures have not evolved at the same pace.
Many organisations are now trying to manage 21st century complexity using governance models built for a far more stable era, one where the principal duty of a charity board was managing risk and providing oversight.
The Public Role of Governance
In the past, charity governance was often viewed as a silent administrative structure operating behind the delivery of a charity – but this distinction no longer exists. Today, governance itself is public-facing.
Audiences, communities, staff, campaign groups and funders increasingly scrutinise who organisations accept money from, how decisions are made, whether trustees are representative, how crises are handled and whether organisations act consistently within their stated values.
This means that the governance challenge is reputational, as much as it is legal. The charity sector is therefore reaching an uncomfortable but necessary moment of reflection: What kind of governance infrastructure is needed for charities to remain viable, resilient and publicly trusted?
The Governance Capacity Emergency
Increasingly, governance determines whether organisations are capable of fast adaption, financial resilience, maintaining public trust and supporting innovation, and remaining fit for purpose often under incredible pressure.
One of the most significant structural problems in the sector is the widening gap between these more contemporary governance expectations and trustee capacity. Large national organisations may have legal advisors, adequate HR infrastructure and dedicated risk committees. However, many smaller charities do not. Smaller organisations often have trustees that are supporting overstretched executive teams with minimal resources to seek financial and legal support, while trying to navigate ambiguous or uncertain funding systems.
Yet the regulatory expectations are increasingly similar, regardless of organisational scale. The result is that effective governance becomes increasingly resource-dependent – and being resource-dependent means that trustees need to give more time – time that is not often available.
This creates a dangerous dynamic: the organisations most vulnerable to external instability are often those least equipped to manage governance complexity. Without proportional governance frameworks, smaller charities risk becoming trapped in cycles of compliance overload and firefighting.
In these conditions it can feel impossible for trustees to think long-term, which can lead to conservatism precisely when innovation is most needed. The charity sector is therefore facing two interconnected predicaments: a governance capacity emergency and one of sustainability.
What Charities Need to Rethink
In this context, charities can support governance development in the following ways:
- Future focused boards – to recruit trustees able to support organisations to evolve and to be strategically powered in areas such as digital transformation (like Imperial War Museum’s dedicated role of ‘digital trustee‘), financial diversification, and reputational governance (like Misfits Theatre and Curve which have a dedicated trustee for reputational fundraising).
- Enterprise thinking – to create board cultures with the skills to embrace commercial activity, earned income, enterprise models and recurring revenue structures, to offset the uncertainties of external funding. An example of existing work in this area includes the People’s History Museum’s recruitment for a Trading Company Board.
- Better trustee accessibility – to continue to adapt board structures and committees to include talents from diverse but also non-traditional backgrounds, including freelancers, community organisers and people with lived experience, like New Art Exchange, which activates alternative voices in governance through a permanent citizens’ assembly.
The Role of Funders and Regulators
But funders also have critical responsibilities, including to:
- Fund governance capacity itself – Funders often require strong governance, while underfunding the infrastructure needed to sustain it. To achieve better outcomes, governance capacity itself must become fundable, taking note from funders such as City Bridge, The Fore and Lloyd’s Bank Foundation, which support governance enhancements and aim to provide wraparound skills development as part of their funding agreements.
- Longer-term funding horizons – Short-term funding cycles actively undermine good governance. Longer-term and more flexible funding like models advocated by organisations such as the Institute for Voluntary Action Research allows organisations to govern strategically rather than defensively.
- Greater tolerance for experimentation – Many funding systems unintentionally reward organisational caution, but resilient organisations often emerge through experimentation and failure. Funders increasingly need to support organisational learning rather than safe bets and to open dialogue with boards wanting to radically change their business models.
- Less duplication and reporting burden – Many charities now manage overlapping reporting systems; governance requirements and compliance structures. This consumes enormous organisational capacity. Simplification and alignment across funders would significantly strengthen sector resilience. One example of good practice is Yorkshire Funders which joined together to create a common reporting form.
For regulators the following adaptations would make a difference:
- Greater clarity around proportionality – Many organisations struggle, not because guidance is absent, but because it is difficult to operationalise proportionately. Smaller charities need scalable frameworks; clearer thresholds and operational guidance.
- Stronger support for preventative governance – Too much governance intervention still occurs after organisational failure or controversy. The sector needs more emphasis on prevention including education, trustee development and governance literacy.
- Recognition that governance now includes reputation and public trust – Modern governance increasingly involves political sensitivity; freedom of expression; sponsorship reputation and activism. Regulatory guidance is gradually evolving in this direction, but organisations would benefit from enhanced practical support in these areas.
The Next Phase of Charitable Governance
The future governance challenge is not simply about preventing failure. It is about enabling charities to remain trusted, financially resilient and capable of innovation under pressure.
This requires a major cultural shift from risk and oversight to governance becoming the operating system through which organisations navigate uncertainty itself. Because the organisations most likely to remain resilient in the next decade may not necessarily be the largest or best funded. They will likely be those most capable of adapting intelligently and balancing organisational purpose with sustainability.
And if charities are expected to carry greater social, cultural and civic responsibility in the years ahead, then governance can no longer be treated as a marginal administrative function. It must be a central infrastructure for public trust, organisational resilience and the long-term sustainability of the sector itself.
